Sunday, May 5, 2013

The Thin Line Between Horror and Comedy


Hallo reader. Tis time for a random post. How lucky for you! … What? …. N-No! I am not being lazy! I am... um... broadening my topics. Yes. I am totally not just being too lazy to write serious intelligent posts. Perish the thought! … -cough- … Moving on.

Recently, a very close friend and I were intrigued by the concept of Doctor Who's weeping angels. We had never actually seen the episode, but we had seen enough to get the gist of the idea. We had always been curious, but could never bother to pull up the actual show. Today we decided to actually satisfy our curiosity and look up a clip from the episode they appear in. The results were... unexpected, and I have been inspired to take this opportunity to talk to you about horror.

For those who are unaware, the weeping angels were monsters from the episode entitled “Blink”. The idea around them was this: They are vicious creatures with the appearance of an angel, until they choose to attack wherein they acquire a more demonic facial expression. They turn to stone whenever they are looked upon by any living thing, including others of their kind. Thus, they cover their eyes before this happens whenever possible, since if they were to accidentally lock eyes with each other, they would remain stone eternally. The idea being they can not look away when turned to stone, and so would be unable the immobilizing gaze. The position of bowing their head and covering their eyes gives them the appearance of crying, thus the name “weeping angels”. They are cruel and viscous, and almost never alone.

Sounds pretty promising right? After all, the idea of being endlessly hunted by these creatures is legitimately terrifying. The idea of being cornered by one, unable to blink or look away, unsure of the location of the others and the ever pressing fear that one could appear behind you while the one in front keeps you trapped, is well... scary. But the execution of this cool concept was just awful. The expressions of the angels became so grotesque and demonic it passed the line into ridiculousness. They honestly looked more like cartoon characters than terrifying creatures of the night. They constantly had their face in a roaring position, and held their clawed hands in an almost Frankenstein manner. The entire tension of the scene was broken by these silly caricatures. When the angels were “weeping”, they were actually more intimidating. There was some thing about the sinister nature of their seemingly innocent nature. It was reminiscent of the angelic statues found in graveyards that these were no doubt modeled after. They were creepier, and created infinitely more tension then their snarling counterparts. The final straw of silliness came when they had the angels “rocking” the tardis (no I am not kidding), without actually really shifting position. It just destroyed any horror qualities they may have had.

So why did this seemingly terrifying concept fall flat? Well in essence, they were simply trying too hard. The beauty of these kinds of creatures is they don't need to look vicious. In fact the more innocuous they appear, the better. When something looks basic or bland, it appears more unearthly and in human. Just look at scp 173 or slenderman to see this kind of idea in action. If the angels had simply always covered their eyes when the characters were looking at them, it would vastly improve the effect they had. The idea of turning away, and suddenly having an angel literally in your face is terrifying. It does not need to roar, or grimace, or threaten you with claws. It just needs to be about five feet closer than it was a few minutes ago. Horror is largely about atmosphere. It is not just about monster design. It is not about fangs and claws. It is about lighting, and isolation, and music. It is the emotion and the paranoia. It is about being helpless and alone in the dark.

-BlackFox

(680)

No comments:

Post a Comment